共查询到20条相似文献，搜索用时 31 毫秒
1.
Won-Chan Lee Stella Y. Kim Jiwon Choi Yujin Kang 《Journal of Educational Measurement》2020,57(2):230-254
This article considers psychometric properties of composite raw scores and transformed scale scores on mixed-format tests that consist of a mixture of multiple-choice and free-response items. Test scores on several mixed-format tests are evaluated with respect to conditional and overall standard errors of measurement, score reliability, and classification consistency and accuracy under three item response theory (IRT) frameworks: unidimensional IRT (UIRT), simple structure multidimensional IRT (SS-MIRT), and bifactor multidimensional IRT (BF-MIRT) models. Illustrative examples are presented using data from three mixed-format exams with various levels of format effects. In general, the two MIRT models produced similar results, while the UIRT model resulted in consistently lower estimates of reliability and classification consistency/accuracy indices compared to the MIRT models. 相似文献
2.
This paper describes four procedures previously developed for estimating conditional standard errors of measurement for scale scores: the IRT procedure (Kolen, Zeng, & Hanson. 1996), the binomial procedure (Brennan & Lee, 1999), the compound binomial procedure (Brennan & Lee, 1999), and the Feldt-Qualls procedure (1998). These four procedures are based on different underlying assumptions. The IRT procedure is based on the unidimensional IRT model assumptions. The binomial and compound binomial procedures employ, as the distribution of errors, the binomial model and compound binomial model, respectively. By contrast, the Feldt-Qualls procedure does not depend on a particular psychometric model, and it simply translates any estimated conditional raw-score SEM to a conditional scale-score SEM. These procedures are compared in a simulation study, which involves two-dimensional data sets. The presence of two category dimensions reflects a violation of the IRT unidimensionality assumption. The relative accuracy of these procedures for estimating conditional scale-score standard errors of measurement is evaluated under various circumstances. The effects of three different types of transformations of raw scores are investigated including developmental standard scores, grade equivalents, and percentile ranks. All the procedures discussed appear viable. A general recommendation is made that test users select a procedure based on various factors such as the type of scale score of concern, characteristics of the test, assumptions involved in the estimation procedure, and feasibility and practicability of the estimation procedure. 相似文献
3.
Sometimes, test‐takers may not be able to attempt all items to the best of their ability (with full effort) due to personal factors (e.g., low motivation) or testing conditions (e.g., time limit), resulting in poor performances on certain items, especially those located toward the end of a test. Standard item response theory (IRT) models fail to consider such testing behaviors. In this study, a new class of mixture IRT models was developed to account for such testing behavior in dichotomous and polytomous items, by assuming test‐takers were composed of multiple latent classes and by adding a decrement parameter to each latent class to describe performance decline. Parameter recovery, effect of model misspecification, and robustness of the linearity assumption in performance decline were evaluated using simulations. It was found that the parameters in the new models were recovered fairly well by using the freeware WinBUGS; the failure to account for such behavior by fitting standard IRT models resulted in overestimation of difficulty parameters on items located toward the end of the test and overestimation of test reliability; and the linearity assumption in performance decline was rather robust. An empirical example is provided to illustrate the applications and the implications of the new class of models. 相似文献
4.
《Educational Assessment》2013,18(2):203-206
This rejoinder responds to the major statements and claims made in Clemans (this issue). The arbitrary and unrealistic assumptions made by the Thurstone procedure are described. We point out the logical inconsistency of Clemans's claim that the relationship between raw scores, and abilities holds when transforming abilities into raw scores but not when transforming raw scores into abilities. Two effects that Clemans claims are caused by item response theory (IRT) scaling are examined, and we demonstrate that they occur more often with Thurstone scaling than with IRT scaling. We reiterate our belief in the superiority of IRT scaling over Thurstone scaling. 相似文献
5.
Lihua Yao 《Journal of Educational Measurement》2010,47(3):339-360
In educational assessment, overall scores obtained by simply averaging a number of domain scores are sometimes reported. However, simply averaging the domain scores ignores the fact that different domains have different score points, that scores from those domains are related, and that at different score points the relationship between overall score and domain score may be different. To report reliable and valid overall scores and domain scores, I investigated the performance of four methods using both real and simulation data: (a) the unidimensional IRT model; (b) the higher-order IRT model, which simultaneously estimates the overall ability and domain abilities; (c) the multidimensional IRT (MIRT) model, which estimates domain abilities and uses the maximum information method to obtain the overall ability; and (d) the bifactor general model. My findings suggest that the MIRT model not only provides reliable domain scores, but also produces reliable overall scores. The overall score from the MIRT maximum information method has the smallest standard error of measurement. In addition, unlike the other models, there is no linear relationship assumed between overall score and domain scores. Recommendations for sizes of correlations between domains and the number of items needed for reporting purposes are provided. 相似文献
6.
《Educational Assessment》2013,18(4):329-347
It is generally accepted that variability in performance will increase throughout Grades 1 to 12. Those with minimal knowledge of a domain should vary but little, but, as learning rates differ, variability should increase as a function of growth. In this article, the series of reading tests from a widely used test battery for Grades 1 through 12 was singled out for study as the scale scores for the series have the opposite characteristic-that is, variability is greatest at Grade 1 and decreases as growth proceeds. Item response theory (IRT) scaling was used; in previous editions, the publisher had used Thurstonian scaling and the variance increased with growth. Using data with known characteristics (i.e., weight distributions for ages 6 through 17), a comparison was made between the effectiveness of IRT and Thurstonian scaling procedures. The Thurstonian scaling more accurately reproduced the characteristics of the known distributions. As IRT scaling was shown to improve when perfect scores were included in the analyses and when items were selected whose difficulties reflected the entire range of ability, these steps were recommended. However, even when these steps were implemented with IRT, the Thurstonian scaling was still found to be more accurate. 相似文献
7.
In this digital ITEMS module, Dr. Brian Leventhal and Dr. Allison Ames provide an overview of Monte Carlo simulation studies (MCSS) in item response theory (IRT). MCSS are utilized for a variety of reasons, one of the most compelling being that they can be used when analytic solutions are impractical or nonexistent because they allow researchers to specify and manipulate an array of parameter values and experimental conditions (e.g., sample size, test length, and test characteristics). Dr. Leventhal and Dr. Ames review the conceptual foundation of MCSS in IRT and walk through the processes of simulating total scores as well as item responses using the two-parameter logistic, graded response, and bifactor models. They provide guidance for how to implement MCSS using other item response models and best practices for efficient syntax and executing an MCSS. The digital module contains sample SAS code, diagnostic quiz questions, activities, curated resources, and a glossary. 相似文献
8.
Standard 3.9 of the Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing ( 1999 ) demands evidence of model fit when item response theory (IRT) models are employed to data from tests. Hambleton and Han ( 2005 ) and Sinharay ( 2005 ) recommended the assessment of practical significance of misfit of IRT models, but few examples of such assessment can be found in the literature concerning IRT model fit. In this article, practical significance of misfit of IRT models was assessed using data from several tests that employ IRT models to report scores. The IRT model did not fit any data set considered in this article. However, the extent of practical significance of misfit varied over the data sets. 相似文献
9.
Testing the goodness of fit of item response theory (IRT) models is relevant to validating IRT models, and new procedures have been proposed. These alternatives compare observed and expected response frequencies conditional on observed total scores, and use posterior probabilities for responses across θ levels rather than cross-classifying examinees using point estimates of θ and score responses. This research compared these alternatives with regard to their methods, properties (Type 1 error rates and empirical power), available research, and practical issues (computational demands, treatment of missing data, effects of sample size and sparse data, and available computer programs). Different advantages and disadvantages related to these characteristics are discussed. A simulation study provided additional information about empirical power and Type 1 error rates. 相似文献
10.
Previous assessments of the reliability of test scores for testlet-composed tests have indicated that item-based estimation
methods overestimate reliability. This study was designed to address issues related to the extent to which item-based estimation
methods overestimate the reliability of test scores composed of testlets and to compare several estimation methods for different
measurement models using simulation techniques. Three types of estimation approach were conceptualized for generalizability
theory (GT) and item response theory (IRT): item score approach (ISA), testlet score approach (TSA), and item-nested-testlet
approach (INTA). The magnitudes of overestimation when applying item-based methods ranged from 0.02 to 0.06 and were related
to the degrees of dependence among within-testlet items. Reliability estimates from TSA were lower than those from INTA due
to the loss of information with IRT approaches. However, this could not be applied in GT. Specified methods in IRT produced
higher reliability estimates than those in GT using the same approach. Relatively smaller magnitudes of error in reliability
estimates were observed for ISA and for methods in IRT. Thus, it seems reasonable to use TSA as well as INTA for both GT and
IRT. However, if there is a relatively large dependence among within-testlet items, INTA should be considered for IRT due
to nonnegligible loss of information. 相似文献
11.
Adam E. Wyse 《Educational Measurement》2017,36(4):16-27
This article illustrates five different methods for estimating Angoff cut scores using item response theory (IRT) models. These include maximum likelihood (ML), expected a priori (EAP), modal a priori (MAP), and weighted maximum likelihood (WML) estimators, as well as the most commonly used approach based on translating ratings through the test characteristic curve (i.e., the IRT true‐score (TS) estimator). The five methods are compared using a simulation study and a real data example. Results indicated that the application of different methods can sometimes lead to different estimated cut scores, and that there can be some key differences in impact data when using the IRT TS estimator compared to other methods. It is suggested that one should carefully think about their choice of methods to estimate ability and cut scores because different methods have distinct features and properties. An important consideration in the application of Bayesian methods relates to the choice of the prior and the potential bias that priors may introduce into estimates. 相似文献
12.
When cut scores for classifications occur on the total score scale, popular methods for estimating classification accuracy (CA) and classification consistency (CC) require assumptions about a parametric form of the test scores or about a parametric response model, such as item response theory (IRT). This article develops an approach to estimate CA and CC nonparametrically by replacing the role of the parametric IRT model in Lee's classification indices with a modified version of Ramsay's kernel‐smoothed item response functions. The performance of the nonparametric CA and CC indices are tested in simulation studies in various conditions with different generating IRT models, test lengths, and ability distributions. The nonparametric approach to CA often outperforms Lee's method and Livingston and Lewis's method, showing robustness to nonnormality in the simulated ability. The nonparametric CC index performs similarly to Lee's method and outperforms Livingston and Lewis's method when the ability distributions are nonnormal. 相似文献
13.
Won-Chan Lee 《Journal of Educational Measurement》2010,47(1):1-17
In this article, procedures are described for estimating single-administration classification consistency and accuracy indices for complex assessments using item response theory (IRT). This IRT approach was applied to real test data comprising dichotomous and polytomous items. Several different IRT model combinations were considered. Comparisons were also made between the IRT approach and two non-IRT approaches including the Livingston-Lewis and compound multinomial procedures. Results for various IRT model combinations were not substantially different. The estimated classification consistency and accuracy indices for the non-IRT procedures were almost always lower than those for the IRT procedures. 相似文献
14.
Item response theory (IRT) methods are generally used to create score scales for large-scale tests. Research has shown that IRT scales are stable across groups and over time. Most studies have focused on items that are dichotomously scored. Now Rasch and other IRT models are used to create scales for tests that include polytomously scored items. When tests are equated across forms, researchers check for the stability of common items before including them in equating procedures. Stability is usually examined in relation to polytomous items' central “location” on the scale without taking into account the stability of the different item scores (step difficulties). We examined the stability of score scales over a 3–5-year period, considering both stability of location values and stability of step difficulties for common item equating. We also investigated possible changes in the scale measured by the tests and systematic scale drift that might not be evident in year-to-year equating. Results across grades and content areas suggest that equating results are comparable whether or not the stability of step difficulties is taken into account. Results also suggest that there may be systematic scale drift that is not visible using year-to-year common item equating. 相似文献
15.
《Educational Assessment》2013,18(2):125-146
States are implementing statewide assessment programs that classify students into proficiency levels that reflect state-defined performance standards. In an effort to provide support for score interpretations, this study examined the consistency of classifications based on competing item response theory (IRT) models for data from a state assessment program. Classification of students into proficiency levels was compared based on a 1-parameter vs. a 3-parameter IRT model. Despite an overall high level of agreement between classifications based on the 2 models, systematic differences were observed. Under the 1-parameter model, proficiency was underestimated for low proficiency classifications but overestimated for upper proficiency classifications. This resulted in higher "Below Basic" and "Advanced" classifications under 1-parameter vs. 3-parameter IRT applications. Implications of these differences are discussed. 相似文献
16.
17.
Haiwen Chen 《Journal of Educational Measurement》2012,49(3):269-284
In this article, linear item response theory (IRT) observed‐score equating is compared under a generalized kernel equating framework with Levine observed‐score equating for nonequivalent groups with anchor test design. Interestingly, these two equating methods are closely related despite being based on different methodologies. Specifically, when using data from IRT models, linear IRT observed‐score equating is virtually identical to Levine observed‐score equating. This leads to the conclusion that poststratification equating based on true anchor scores can be viewed as the curvilinear Levine observed‐score equating. 相似文献
18.
ABSTRACTCurrent procedures for equating number-correct scores using traditional item response theory (IRT) methods assume local independence. However, when tests are constructed using testlets, one concern is the violation of the local item independence assumption. The testlet response theory (TRT) model is one way to accommodate local item dependence. This study proposes methods to extend IRT true score and observed score equating methods to the dichotomous TRT model. We also examine the impact of local item dependence on equating number-correct scores when a traditional IRT model is applied. Results of the study indicate that when local item dependence is at a low level, using the three-parameter logistic model does not substantially affect number-correct equating. However, when local item dependence is at a moderate or high level, using the three-parameter logistic model generates larger equating bias and standard errors of equating compared to the TRT model. However, observed score equating is more robust to the violation of the local item independence assumption than is true score equating. 相似文献
19.
In educational and psychological measurement, a person-fit statistic (PFS) is designed to identify aberrant response patterns. For parametric PFSs, valid inference depends on several assumptions, one of which is that the item response theory (IRT) model is correctly specified. Previous studies have used empirical data sets to explore the effects of model misspecification on PFSs. We further this line of research by using a simulation study, which allows us to explore issues that may be of interest to practitioners. Results show that, depending on the generating and analysis item models, Type I error rates at fixed values of the latent variable may be greatly inflated, even when the aggregate rates are relatively accurate. Results also show that misspecification is most likely to affect PFSs for examinees with extreme latent variable scores. Two empirical data analyses are used to illustrate the importance of model specification. 相似文献
20.
The posterior predictive model checking method is a flexible Bayesian model‐checking tool and has recently been used to assess fit of dichotomous IRT models. This paper extended previous research to polytomous IRT models. A simulation study was conducted to explore the performance of posterior predictive model checking in evaluating different aspects of fit for unidimensional graded response models. A variety of discrepancy measures (test‐level, item‐level, and pair‐wise measures) that reflected different threats to applications of graded IRT models to performance assessments were considered. Results showed that posterior predictive model checking exhibited adequate power in detecting different aspects of misfit for graded IRT models when appropriate discrepancy measures were used. Pair‐wise measures were found more powerful in detecting violations of the unidimensionality and local independence assumptions. 相似文献