Images of Science Linked to Labwork: A Survey of Secondary School and University Students     

Séré  Marie-Geneviève  Fernandez-Gonzalez  Manuel  Gallegos  Jose A.  Gonzalez-Garcia  Francisco  De Manuel  Esteban  Perales  F. Javier  Leach  John 《Research in Science Education》2001,31(4):499-523

This paper presents findings about the images of science drawn upon in laboratory work, by upper secondary and university students, in academic streams with a science focus. Data were collected through four written questions, administered to a total of 368 students. The questions all required students to comment on laboratory investigations carried out by research scientists or by science students. We show that students' reasoning has an epistemological and an ontological dimension, and that it often differs significantly from accepted perspectives on the nature of science. The issue for teaching appears to be showing students what counts (and what does not count) as appropriate reasoning in actual situations. In other words, explicit teaching about the various relationships that can exist between theory and data would transform labwork towards a more critical process that involves making and justifying decisions.  相似文献