首页 | 本学科首页   官方微博 | 高级检索  
     检索      

中文科技期刊争鸣论文发表现状与影响力分析——兼与国外科技期刊比较
引用本文:黄锦华,魏秀菊,廖艳,王柳,刘丽英,赵爱琴,刘晨霞.中文科技期刊争鸣论文发表现状与影响力分析——兼与国外科技期刊比较[J].中国科技期刊研究,2018,29(3):278-283.
作者姓名:黄锦华  魏秀菊  廖艳  王柳  刘丽英  赵爱琴  刘晨霞
作者单位:农业部规划设计研究院博士后科研工作站,北京市朝阳区麦子店街41号 100125; 农业部规划设计研究院,中国农业工程学会《农业工程学报》编辑部,北京市朝阳区麦子店街41号 100125,农业部规划设计研究院博士后科研工作站,北京市朝阳区麦子店街41号 100125; 农业部规划设计研究院,中国农业工程学会《农业工程学报》编辑部,北京市朝阳区麦子店街41号 100125,农业部规划设计研究院,中国农业工程学会《农业工程学报》编辑部,北京市朝阳区麦子店街41号 100125,农业部规划设计研究院,中国农业工程学会《农业工程学报》编辑部,北京市朝阳区麦子店街41号 100125,农业部规划设计研究院,中国农业工程学会《农业工程学报》编辑部,北京市朝阳区麦子店街41号 100125,农业部规划设计研究院,中国农业工程学会《农业工程学报》编辑部,北京市朝阳区麦子店街41号 100125,农业部规划设计研究院博士后科研工作站,北京市朝阳区麦子店街41号 100125; 农业部规划设计研究院,中国农业工程学会《农业工程学报》编辑部,北京市朝阳区麦子店街41号 100125
基金项目:中国科协精品科技期刊工程项目[学术出版研究](2015KJQK002)
摘    要:【目的】 分析中文科技期刊争鸣论文发表现状,探讨促进学术争鸣的途径。【方法】 以中国知网为检索平台,通过对2007—2016年农业科技类中文核心期刊群的统计分析,建立争鸣论文数量估算模型,模型通过验证后,用于估算其他自然学科期刊群争鸣论文数量,分析近10年来自然科技中文核心期刊争鸣论文发表及被引情况,并将农业科技期刊争鸣论文的发表情况与同期相应的国外期刊进行对比。【结果】 自然科技中文核心期刊争鸣论文占同期发表论文的0.012%~0.037%,占比由高到低排序为基础科学、医药卫生科技、工程科技、农业科技,其中农业科技类占比仅为0.012%,低于同期国外农业科技期刊的0.055%。对比分析争鸣论文与一般研究论文的影响发现,涉及重要热点科学问题的争鸣论文被引频次较高,影响力较大。【结论】 提出定量研究的方法模型,为其他海量文献统计提供了方法参考;我国自然科技中文核心期刊争鸣论文数量较少,学术争鸣气氛不够活跃,原因包括中庸的学术作风、趋同跟风的研究众多、视学术争鸣为人身攻击等认识误区;科技期刊可通过发表针对具有争鸣价值话题的评论性论文、鼓励读者参与对已发表论文的争鸣、刊发虽存在不完善之处但有着创新价值的研究成果等措施来引导学术争鸣的开展,从而推动科技创新和进步。

关 键 词:科技期刊  学术争鸣  学术繁荣  科技创新
收稿时间:2017/7/22 0:00:00
修稿时间:2018/1/12 0:00:00

Publishing status and influence of contention papers in Chinese scientific journals: Comparison with foreign scientific journals
HUANG Jinhu,WEI Xiuju,LIAO Yan,WANG Liu,LIU Liying,ZHAO Aiqin and LIU Chenxia.Publishing status and influence of contention papers in Chinese scientific journals: Comparison with foreign scientific journals[J].Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals,2018,29(3):278-283.
Authors:HUANG Jinhu  WEI Xiuju  LIAO Yan  WANG Liu  LIU Liying  ZHAO Aiqin and LIU Chenxia
Institution:Postdoctoral Scientific Research Stations of Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering, 41 Maizidian Street, Chaoyang District, Beijing 100125, China; Editorial Office of Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering, 41 Maizidian Street, Chaoyang District, Beijing 100125, China,Postdoctoral Scientific Research Stations of Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering, 41 Maizidian Street, Chaoyang District, Beijing 100125, China; Editorial Office of Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering, 41 Maizidian Street, Chaoyang District, Beijing 100125, China,Editorial Office of Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering, 41 Maizidian Street, Chaoyang District, Beijing 100125, China,Editorial Office of Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering, 41 Maizidian Street, Chaoyang District, Beijing 100125, China,Editorial Office of Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering, 41 Maizidian Street, Chaoyang District, Beijing 100125, China,Editorial Office of Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering, 41 Maizidian Street, Chaoyang District, Beijing 100125, China and Postdoctoral Scientific Research Stations of Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering, 41 Maizidian Street, Chaoyang District, Beijing 100125, China; Editorial Office of Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering, 41 Maizidian Street, Chaoyang District, Beijing 100125, China
Abstract:
Keywords:Scientific journal  Academic contention  Academic prosperity  Technology innovation
点击此处可从《中国科技期刊研究》浏览原始摘要信息
点击此处可从《中国科技期刊研究》下载免费的PDF全文
设为首页 | 免责声明 | 关于勤云 | 加入收藏

Copyright©北京勤云科技发展有限公司  京ICP备09084417号