首页 | 本学科首页   官方微博 | 高级检索  
     检索      

42种中华医学会系列杂志编辑质量审读结果分析
引用本文:李贵存,刘小梅.42种中华医学会系列杂志编辑质量审读结果分析[J].编辑学报,2002,14(1):36-38.
作者姓名:李贵存  刘小梅
作者单位:中华儿科杂志编辑部,100710,北京
摘    要:为了解中华医学会系列杂志在编辑质量方面存在的问题,探讨改进措施,组织了刊后审读.指定抽检每种杂志1997年第1期.实行扣分制,没有基础分,允许出现负分.复审员负责统计并填写审读表.42种杂志最高得分89.4分,最低-13.5分,平均52.39分.60分以上者21刊,占50%;30分以下者10刊,占23.81%.影响中华系列杂志编辑质量的主要因素有9个项目,依次为:目次、关键词、错别字、文献、题名、图表、人名、计量单位、版权.17个受检项目中,页码与文种2项属违反国家有关政策与法规的问题.封面、版权、目次、书脊、页眉等5个项目违反中华医学会系列杂志的编辑规范.封面、版权、目次、书脊、页眉、人名、关键词、文献、错别字等项目的错误是由于编校者责任心不强、工作不认真所致.题名、图表、计量单位、统计学、错别字等项目发生问题的原因主要是编辑人员知识面窄.复审具有能提供可靠的统计数据,便于了解全面情况,及时发现问题,消除差异的作用.

关 键 词:期刊  编辑  质量  审读
修稿时间:2001年3月29日

Analyses on re-checking results of editing quality with 42 journals published by Chinese Medical Association
Li Guicun,Liu Xiaomei Office of CMA Entrusted Publication of Medical Journals,Beijing,China.Analyses on re-checking results of editing quality with 42 journals published by Chinese Medical Association[J].Acta Editologica,2002,14(1):36-38.
Authors:Li Guicun  Liu Xiaomei Office of CMA Entrusted Publication of Medical Journals    Beijing  China
Institution:Li Guicun,Liu Xiaomei Office of CMA Entrusted Publication of Medical Journals,100710,Beijing,China
Abstract:A post publication re checking was conducted to find out the problems existing in the editing of the journals entrusted by the Chinese Medical Association.The first issues of 42 journals published in 1997 were used as the samples. Every journals was given a point by deducting from 100 after the error checking. The results of the re checking are: the highest point in the 42 journals is 89.4, the lowest is minus -13.5 and the average is 52.39, there are 21 journals getting the points over 60, occupying 50% of the total, 10 journals below 30, occupying 23.81%. In all of the 17 checked items, the main ones affecting the journals' quality are the mistakes in the contents and the
Keywords:the wrong characters and spellings  the improper bibliography  the inappropriate titles  the problems in the tables and figures  in the personal names  in the measurement units  and finally in the copyright information  The analyses of the resu  
本文献已被 CNKI 维普 万方数据 等数据库收录!
设为首页 | 免责声明 | 关于勤云 | 加入收藏

Copyright©北京勤云科技发展有限公司  京ICP备09084417号